Marcus T.
·May 2026
Best hoagie in Buffalo, no contest. The bread is baked fresh every morning and it shows. Get the Italian combo — it is everything.
What guests are saying
The Hoagie Stop
4.7
Based on 142 reviews
Synced live from Google Business
5
3
4
2
3
1
2
0
1
0
Filter6 reviews
Sara K.
·May 2026
Came in for lunch on a weekday and it was absolutely packed. That tells you everything. Massive portions, fair prices, genuinely friendly staff.
SayaOwner response · April 2026
Thank you Sara — weekday lunches are our busiest and it means a lot to hear that. See you next time!
Derek M.
·May 2026
Solid neighbourhood spot. The roast beef is the move. Lines move fast even when it is busy. Only reason it is not 5 stars is the parking situation.
SayaOwner response · April 2026
Thanks Derek — parking on Main St is tough, we know. Street parking on Hertel one block up is usually the move. Hope to see you back!
Jenna L.
·May 2026
I drove 40 minutes specifically for the meatball parm. Zero regrets. This place is the real deal.
Chris B.
·May 2026
Great hoagies, generous with the toppings. Turkey club is my go-to. Service is fast and the people working there clearly enjoy what they do.
Amy W.
·May 2026
Decent food but it was very busy when I went and wait time was longer than expected. The hoagie itself was good though — will come back on a quieter day.
SayaOwner response · March 2026
Hi Amy — sorry your visit landed on a hectic one. Come before 11am or after 2pm and you will breeze right through. Hope to see you again soon!
Eaten with us recently?
Leave a review on Google.
It shows up here automatically within 24 hours. Honest words help us — and the next guest deciding where to eat.